10 Best Anna Maria Island Restaurants for Fresh Seafood

When planning your stay on Anna Maria Island, nestled along Florida’s stunning Gulf Coast, don’t miss out on the culinary treasures waiting to be discovered, particularly if you’re a seafood lover. 

Whether you’re a local or a visitor, exploring the vibrant dining scene of this charming island is one of the best things to do on Anna Maria Island and is an essential part of your experience. Indulge in the freshest catches and ocean delights at some of the finest seafood at Anna Maria Island restaurants.

Discover ten establishments that promise a delectable dining experience, showcasing the island’s rich culinary heritage and coastal charm.

The Sandbar Restaurant

The Sandbar Restaurant, nestled on the shores of Anna Maria Island, is a culinary gem managed by the esteemed Chiles family. Renowned for its unwavering commitment to ethical sourcing, this restaurant prides itself on using locally sourced ingredients, ensuring a fresh and sustainable dining experience.

While dining at The Sandbar, guests are treated to a feast for the senses, with panoramic views of the Gulf serving as a picturesque backdrop to their meal. The menu boasts an array of classic dishes, each crafted with meticulous attention to detail. 

One standout offering is the stuffed half Maine lobster, a decadent delight that perfectly balances the sweetness of the lobster with the earthiness of farm-fresh vegetables and parsley potatoes. 

Waterfront Restaurant

Waterfront Restaurant, a culinary haven situated along the scenic shores of Anna Maria Island, is a testament to the island’s vibrant dining scene. Boasting a menu that evolves with the changing seasons, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

One of the highlights of the menu is the Frutti Di Mare, a tantalizing seafood medley featuring Key West Pink Shrimp, scallops, mussels, and clams bathed in a flavorful garlic sauce. Each bite is a harmonious blend of fresh flavors and oceanic delights, transporting diners to coastal paradises with every mouthful.

Another must-try dish at Waterfront Restaurant is the Scallops Trovalo, a culinary masterpiece that showcases the chef’s creativity and skill. Pan-seared to perfection, the jumbo sea scallops are accompanied by an array of wild mushrooms, roasted garlic, and savory herbs, creating a symphony of flavors that dance on the palate.

Rod and Reel Pier

Rod and Reel Pier, a beloved spot for locals and tourists alike, epitomizes the charm of Anna Maria Island dining. Perched at the end of a scenic pier, it offers a delightful selection of traditional dishes and signature fish specials that keep patrons coming back.

Enter the inviting ambiance of Rod and Reel Pier, where the aroma of fresh seafood mingles with the sound of crashing waves, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience. Whether enjoying a casual meal with family or a romantic dinner for two, the pier’s relaxed atmosphere and breathtaking waterfront views provide the perfect backdrop.

Beach House Restaurant

Beach House Restaurant, an Anna Maria Island gem, is celebrated for its seafood towers and oyster selections. Situated along the shoreline, it offers a culinary journey celebrating the sea’s bounty. Whether indoors or on the patio, guests enjoy panoramic Gulf views. Indulge in fresh clams, mussels, crabs, oysters, and shrimp arranged in towering displays. 

Don’t miss their legendary seafood gumbo. Each bite showcases locally sourced ingredients. Beach House Restaurant has earned its culinary destination status, offering unforgettable dining experiences capturing the essence of island living.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier

Anna Maria Oyster Bar on the Pier, overlooking the serene Intracoastal Waterway, is a beloved local spot adored for its delectable seafood offerings and relaxed vibe. Recently reopened, it’s a must-visit for guests at Anna Maria Island’s beachfront hotels.

Whether seated on the breezy outdoor deck or in the cozy indoor bar, diners enjoy panoramic water views, enhancing their dining experience. The talented culinary team crafts tempting coastal classics like coconut shrimp and chipotle oysters on the menu.

Every bite is a celebration of the island’s culinary heritage and abundant seafood, from crispy coconut-crusted shrimp to flavorful chipotle-infused oysters. 

person holding an oyster to eat
Photo from Shutterstock

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant

Blue Marlin Seafood Restaurant, nestled in Anna Maria Island’s heart, is adored by locals and tourists. Offering refined seafood dishes, it invites guests to a Gulf flavor celebration. Inside, the cozy ambiance and nautical decor set the scene. Indoors or on the patio, each table offers a view of culinary mastery. 

Experience innovative dishes like prawn and monk curry or soy-dipped wakame seaweed Sole fillet crafted with fresh seafood and local ingredients. Live music adds charm to your dining. Whether with loved ones or for a romantic dinner, Blue Marlin promises an unforgettable taste of Anna Maria’s coastal essence.

The Feast Restaurant

The Feast Restaurant on Anna Maria Island offers a seasonal menu showcasing the freshest regional ingredients, including succulent crab-stuffed shrimp and flavorful spear-caught hogfish. Complete your dining experience with irresistible desserts, from decadent chocolate creations to refreshing sorbets, crafted with care for a sweet ending.

Bridge Street Bistro

Located on the popular Bridge Street on Anna Maria Island, Bridge Street Bistro entices timeless charm and classic seafood dishes. Its menu pays homage to coastal cuisine, featuring favorites like impeccably seared ahi tuna, savory black bean cakes, and sumptuously baked oysters. 

Don’t miss their signature surf and turf dish, a harmonious blend of land and sea flavors. Each bite transports guests to a culinary paradise, showcasing expert craftsmanship and the freshest ingredients.

The Ugly Grouper

The Ugly Grouper beckons with its lively atmosphere and energetic live music scene. It offers a casual dining experience perfect for enjoying classic seafood comfort foods with friends and family. From the creamy fettuccine shrimp to the crispy fish and chips, every dish at The Ugly Grouper is designed to satisfy the soul and fuel the fun.

As guests savor their meals, they’re treated to the sounds of local musical talents, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to an already memorable dining experience. Whether it’s a lazy afternoon lunch or a lively evening out, The Ugly Grouper offers a laid-back ambiance and mouthwatering cuisine that keep patrons coming back time and time again.

Plan Your Visit

Finding the perfect accommodation is essential when visiting Anna Maria Island to ensure a memorable and comfortable stay. Anna Maria Beach Resort offers a range of lodging options that cater to various preferences and needs. Book your stay now!

Beach Bistro

Beach Bistro offers a refined dining experience perfect for special occasions and romantic evenings. Nestled along the pristine shores of Anna Maria Island, this upscale eatery invites guests to indulge in gourmet seafood bouillabaisses and innovative takes on the beloved grouper.

As diners linger over their meals, they’re treated to impeccable service and breathtaking views of the Gulf, creating an ambiance that’s as enchanting as it is elegant. Whether it’s a first date or a milestone anniversary, Beach Bistro promises an unforgettable dining experience that captures the essence of romance and relaxation in every bite.

Stay with Anna Maria Beach Resort 

Finding the perfect accommodation is essential when visiting Anna Maria Island to ensure a memorable and comfortable stay. Anna Maria Beach Resort offers a range of lodging options that cater to various preferences and needs.

Nestled along the pristine shores of the Gulf of Mexico, Anna Maria Beach Resort boasts luxurious beachfront accommodations with stunning views and direct access to the sugar-white sands. Guests can choose from spacious suites, cozy cottages, and elegant villas, each thoughtfully designed and appointed with modern amenities to ensure a relaxing stay.

Whether you’re planning a romantic retreat, a family vacation, or a solo adventure, this idyllic beachfront oasis among Anna Maria Island beachfront resorts offers everything you need for an unforgettable experience.